Fidelity To Law Meaning Here

, who argued that a legal system must possess an "inner morality" to command true fidelity. Core Meanings The Obligation to Obey : At its simplest, it is the moral and legal obligation to follow established laws and norms. Constraint on Power

The great tension arises when law and justice part ways. Consider a morally abhorrent but clearly written statute. Is fidelity still required? Legal philosopher Lon Fuller argued that law has an "inner morality"—a system so unjust (e.g., Nazi decrees) may lose its claim to being law at all. Others, like H.L.A. Hart, maintain that fidelity demands we call an unjust rule what it is: bad law , but law nonetheless, which we then have a moral duty to change through legislation, not judicial fiat. fidelity to law meaning

argues that fidelity requires adhering to the original public meaning of the constitutional text at the time it was ratified. To do otherwise, originalists say, is to allow judges to amend the Constitution without following Article V's amendment process. , who argued that a legal system must